EPO: Decision in G1/25 – When claim amendments require adaptation of the description
Share article
In its recent decision G 1/25, the Enlarged Board of Appeal of the EPO addressed whether the description of a patent application or patent must be adapted to avoid inconsistencies with amended claims. It held that, where claims of a European patent or patent application are amended in proceedings before any department of the EPO or in appeal proceedings, and the amendment introduces an inconsistency between the amended claims and the description or drawings, and because of that inconsistency Articles 52 to 57, 76(1), 83, 84, 123(2) or 123(3) EPC are not complied with, the description or drawings must be amended to remove that inconsistency.
Questions answered by the Enlarged Board of Appeal
In its referral decision, a Technical Board of Appeal referred three questions to the Enlarged Board of Appeal. The first asked whether the description must be amended to comply with the EPC if a claim amendment made in opposition or opposition-appeal proceedings creates an inconsistency between the amended claims and the description. The second concerned the legal basis in the EPC for requiring such an adaptation. The third asked whether the same or different principles apply to claim amendments in examination or examination-appeal proceedings, and how inconsistencies should be addressed in those cases.
The Enlarged Board of Appeal held that all three questions were admissible.
On the first question, the Enlarged Board of Appeal held that an amendment to the description is required if there is a genuine inconsistency between the amended claims and the description that cannot be resolved through the holistic approach to interpretation set out in G 1/24 and that results in non-compliance with a requirement of the EPC. G 1/24 emphasised that the claims must be read and interpreted in light of the description and drawings. Against this background, the Enlarged Board of Appeal found that an inconsistency exists where statements in the description suggest an understanding of a claim that is incompatible with its apparent meaning and the incompatibility cannot readily be resolved by holistic interpretation.
However, it found no blanket requirement to amend the description or delete passages describing embodiments that are no longer covered by the claim. An adaptation is required only where the inconsistency has legal significance because it results in non-compliance with a requirement of the EPC. If, for example, due to such incompatibility, it is unclear whether a technical teaching, examples, or embodiments do, or do not fall within the claimed subject matter, an inconsistency exists and then it cannot be said that the claim is supported by the description. In this case, adaption of the description is required.
On the second question, concerning the legal basis in the EPC, the Enlarged Board of Appeal held that there is no single provision that requires the description or drawings to be adapted whenever the claims are amended. The Board finds that the legal basis for any necessary adaptation is the EPC provision with which compliance is lacking because of the inconsistency in question. The decision refers in particular to Article 84 EPC and Articles 52 to 57 EPC. Other articles might also come into play, but more rarely.
On the third question, the Enlarged Board of Appeal held that there is no difference in this respect between opposition or opposition-appeal proceedings and examination or examination-appeal proceedings. The same principles apply.
Will this decision change day-to-day practice before the EPO?
The finding that there is no blanket requirement to amend the description or delete passages referring to embodiments that are no longer covered may help, in certain instances, to avoid unnecessary or excessive amendments to the description. The decision states that the description must be adapted only where, and to the extent that, the inconsistency leads to non-compliance with a requirement of the EPC. The EPC, however, does not require an adaptation merely for the sake of formal concordance.
The decision is therefore likely to limit the extent to which amendments to the description are required in individual cases. However, no fundamental change in practice before the EPO is to be expected, given that adapting the description to amended claims is already common practice. There may be some flexibility, in particular in cases where a feature that is mandatory under the claim is described in the description as merely optional. We believe that such a discrepancy does generally not give rise to any lack of clarity as to the scope of protection, so that the EPO may consider an amendment of the description unnecessary. In our experience, this line of argument is already occasionally accepted by Opposition Divisions.
In its “Obiter remarks”, the Board of Appeal further emphasizes that amendments of the claims and the description are part of the same procedural step, even if there is a lapse of time between these amendments. This remark seems to be directed to common practice in examination proceedings, where the examining division often requests amending the description only once the claims are found to be patentable. Thus, the Board seems to approve this common practice.
In appeal proceedings, amendments to the description are usually finalized in the oral proceedings before the Board and, according to the obiter remarks, the present decision does not call for a change to this practice.
See the full decision here:
https://www.epo.org/en/boards-of-appeal/decisions/g250001ex1?term=%22G%200001%5C%2F25%22